                     CATALOG DOCUMENTATION 
             EMAP-ESTUARIES PROGRAM LEVEL DATABASE 
                    1992 VIRGINIAN PROVINCE 
                  SEDIMENT TOXICITY TEST DATA 
                                
                                
                       TABLE OF CONTENTS


	1.  DATA SET IDENTIFICATION 

	2.  INVESTIGATOR INFORMATION

	3.  DATA SET ABSTRACT 

	4.  OBJECTIVES AND INTRODUCTION

	5.  DATA ACQUISTION AND PROCESSING METHODS

	6.  DATA MANIPULATIONS

	7.  DATA DESCRIPTION 

	8.  GEOGRAPHIC AND SPATIAL INFORMATION 

	9.  QUALITY CONTROL/QUALITY ASSURANCE

	10. DATA ACCESS

	11. REFERENCES

	12. TABLE OF ACRONYMS 

	13. PERSONNEL INFORMATION 


1.  DATA SET IDENTIFICATION 

  1.1  Title of Catalog document 

     EMAP-Estuaries Program Level Database
     1992 Virginian Province 
     Sediment Toxicity Test Data

  1.2  Authors of the Catalog entry

     Charles Strobel, US EPA NHEERL-AED
     Melissa Hughes, OAO Corp. 

  1.3  Catalog revision date 

     14 March 1996 

  1.4  Data set name 

     Toxicity 

  1.5  Task Group

     Estuaries

  1.6  Data set identification code 

     00064

  1.7  Version

     001 

  1.8  Requested Acknowledgement

     If you plan to publish these data in any way, EPA requires a
     standard statement for work it has supported:

     "Although the data described in this article have been
     funded wholly or in part by the U. S. Environmental
     Protection Agency through its EMAP-Estuaries Program, it has
     not been subjected to Agency review, and therefore does not
     necessarily reflect the views of the Agency and no official
     endorsement should be inferred."

2.  INVESTIGATOR INFORMATION

  2.1  Principal Investigator

     Darryl Keith 
     U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
     NHEERL-AED 

  2.2.  Investigation Participant-Sample Collection 

     Charles J. Strobel
     U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
     NHEERL-AED 

  2.3  Sample Processing-Principal Investigator

     Dr. K. John Scott
     Science Applications International Corporation, Inc. 

3.  DATA SET ABSTRACT 

  3.1  Abstract of the Data Set 

     The SEDIMENT TOXICITY TEST data set provides summary data on
     a sediment toxicity test associated with a station.  The
     test was conducted using an homogenized sample composed of
     several grabs.  A static ten-day sediment toxicity test was
     conducted using the amphipod Ampelisca abdita.  The mean
     test sample survival as per cent of the mean control
     survival is presented.  A flag indicates if test and control
     mortalities were significantly different.  

  3.2  Keywords for the Data Set 

     Sediment toxicity test, toxicity test results, amphipod,
     Ampelisca, marine amphipod 

4.  OBJECTIVES AND INTRODUCTION

  4.1  Program Objective

     The Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program (EMAP)
     was designed to periodically estimate the status and trends
     of the Nation's ecological resources on a regional basis. 
     EMAP provides a strategy to identify and bound the extent,
     magnitude and location of environmental degradation and
     improvement on a regional scale based on randomly located
     station sites.  Only Base Sampling Sites (BASE) were
     included in this data set.  Sediment toxicity testing is
     considered a core indicator in the EMAP program for which
     there presently exists sufficient data to define the
     sensitivity and reliability of responses to stress with a
     high degree of confidence.  

  4.2  Data Set Objective

     The toxicity of estuarine sediments to the amphipod
     Ampelisca abdita was estimated in a 10-day, static
     laboratory exposure.  

  4.3  Data Set Background Information 

     Sediment toxicity tests are the most direct measure
     available for estimating the potential for contaminant-induced effects 
     in benthic communities.  These tests provide information that is 
     independent of chemical characterizations and ecological surveys.  
     They improve upon direct measures of contaminants because many 
     chemicals are bound tightly to sediment particles or are complexed
     chemically, making them biologically unavailable.  Mortality
     in these laboratory exposure tests can provide evidence of
     toxic contamination without requiring interpretation of how
     complex mixtures might interact to affect biota.  However,
     sediment toxicity cannot be used entirely in replacement of
     direct measurement of sediment contaminant concentrations,
     since the latter is an important part of interpreting
     observed mortality in toxicity tests. 

     Although amphipod toxicity test methods have gained general
     acceptance, a number of factors that affect their
     application over the broad geographic and habitat range were
     assessed by EMAP-Estuaries.  Salinity effects are also a
     potential concern.  Sediment exposure tests for EMAP were
     all conducted at the same salinity using full strength
     seawater (30 ppt), regardless of the salinity at the
     collection site;  thus, low salinity sediments were adjusted
     to full strength salinity for the test.  This increase in
     salinity may have decreased bioavailability of metal
     contaminants. 

  4.4  Summary of Data Set Parameters

     A summary of replicate sediment toxicity test results were 
     compared to summary test control data.  The ten-day test was
     conducted with the amphipod, Ampelisca abdita.  A sediment
     homogenate was used which was derived from several samples
     collected at a station. 

5.  DATA ACQUISITION AND PROCESSING METHODS 

  5.1  Data Acquisition 

     5.1.1  Sampling Objective

     Collect one sediment sample per station suitable to conduct
     a sediment toxicity test with a marine organism.  One
     sediment sample was expected to be collected at each
     station.  
 
     5.1.2  Sample Collection Methods Summary 

     The grab sampler was lowered through the water column such
     that travel through the last 5 meters is no faster than 1
     m/sec.  This minimized the effects of bow wave disturbance
     to surficial sediments.  The grab penetrated the sediment by
     gravity releasing a trigger allowing the jaws to close. 
     When the grab was pulled from the sediment using the winch,
     the jaws closed, encapsulating the sediment sample.  The
     sampler was retrieved and lowered into an on-board cradle.  

     A successful grab had relatively level, intact sediment over
     the entire area of the grab and a sediment depth at the
     center of > 7 centimeters.  Unacceptable grabs included
     those:  not containing any sediment, which were partially
     filled, had shelly substrates or grossly slumped surfaces or
     were completely filled to the top, where the sediment was
     oozing out of the hinged top.  

     To minimize the chance of sampling the exact location twice,
     after three grabs were taken, the boat was moved five meters
     downstream by letting out the appropriate length of anchor
     line.

     Large items in the grab such as rocks or pieces of wood were
     removed from the sediment.  The top two centimeters of the
     sediment at least one cm from the edge of the sample were
     removed using a stainless steel spoon (all items were washed
     with Alconox and rinsed with ambient seawater before use). 
     The sediment was placed in a pan or pot and placed in a
     cooler on ice for refrigerated storage.  This procedure was
     repeated with each sediment grab collected until at least
     3,000 cc of sediment had been collected.  The sediment
     composite was then homogenized by stirring with a spoon for
     10 minutes.  Using a spoon, approximately 3,000 cc of the
     sediment homogenate was placed in a container for toxicity
     testing.  The toxicity sample bottle was placed on ice. 

     5.1.3  Beginning Sampling Date  

     27 July 1992

     5.1.4  Ending Sampling Date  

     31 August 1992 

     5.1.5  Platform 

     Sampling was conducted from 8 m (24 ft), twin-engine
     Chesapeake style workboats.

     5.1.6  Sampling Equipment

     A 1/25 m2, stainless steel, Young-modified Van Veen Grab
     sampler was used to collect sediments.  This grab sampled an
     area of 440 cm2 and a maximum depth of penetration in the
     sediment of 10 cm.

     5.1.7  Manufacturer of Sampling Equipment 

     Young's Welding, Sandwich, MA

     5.1.8  Key Variables

     This data set does not contain any values which were
     measured at the time of collection.  Analysis of the data
     after completion of the tests produced summary results. 

     5.1.9  Sampling Method Calibration

     The sampling gear did not require any calibration.  It
     required inspection for deformities incurred due to
     mishandling or impact on rocky substrates.

     5.1.10 Sample Collection Quality Control

     Prior to sampling at each station, the grab sampler was
     washed with Alconox and thoroughly rinsed with ambient
     seawater to ensure that no sediment remained from a previous
     station.  The spoon and processing (homogenizing) container
     used to process the sediment sample in the field were Teflon
     or stainless steel coated with Kynar.  The sample container
     was a one-gallon plastic jar.

     To minimize airborne contamination, all engines were shut
     down when ever sediment containers were open. 

     5.1.11 Sample Collection Method Reference 

     Reifsteck, D.R., Strobel, C.J. and S.C. Schimmel. 
     1992.  Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
     Program-Near Coastal Component:  1992 Virginian
     Province Effort Field Operations and Safety Manual.
     U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED, Narragansett, RI.  June 1992. 

     5.1.12 Sample Collection Method Deviations 

     None 

5.2  Data Preparation and Sample Processing

     5.2.1  Sample Processing Objective

     Process uncontaminated sediment samples for characterization
     of sediment toxicity to the amphipod Ampelisca abdita. 

     5.2.2  Sample Processing Methods Summary 

     Each test replicate consisted of 200 mL of sediment sample
     (roughly 4 cm in depth) in a quart-size canning jar covered
     with 600 mL of aerated water.  The east coast marine
     amphipod Ampelisca abdita was employed as the test species
     for all sediment samples collected.  Tests were conducted
     for 10 days under static conditions at a constant
     temperature of 20 degrees C and dissolved oxygen
     concentration >60% of saturation.  The overlying water in A.
     abdita tests was 30 ppt seawater.  Five replicate test
     chambers, each containing 20 organisms, were tested with
     sediment from each station along with a control treatment
     containing known uncontaminated sediment. 

     Control treatments used the same water, conditions,
     procedures, and organisms as the other test treatments,
     except that none of the test material was added to the
     control sediment or water.  The control treatments were used
     to provide: a) a measure of the acceptability of the test by
     providing evidence of the health and relative quality of the
     test organisms, and the suitability of the overlying water,
     test conditions, and handling procedures, etc.; and b) the
     basis for interpreting data obtained from the test
     sediments. 

     Mortality and sublethal effects such as emergence from the
     sediment were determined during and after exposure to the
     test sediment.  Dead animals were counted and removed daily. 
     At the end of the 10 day exposure, the test sediments were
     rinsed through a 0.5 mm mesh sieve.  The material retained
     on the sieve was either examined that day or preserved in 5%
     buffered formalin with Rose Bengal stain for later
     examination.  Any amphipods which were not accounted for
     when the sieved material was examined were presumed to have
     died during the test.  Survival in control treatments of
     <85% resulted in the entire test being repeated, discarded
     or flagged.

     5.2.3  Sample Processing Method Calibration 

     NA

     5.2.4  Sample Processing Quality Control 

     Samples were chilled when collected and shipped on ice.
     Sediment toxicity samples were stored in the dark at 4 Deg C
     until used.  The samples were tested within 30 days of
     collection.  

     Sediment samples were thoroughly homogenized within the
     storage container and press sieved through a stainless steel
     screen (1.0 mm mesh) to remove predators and larger
     particles (e.g., rocks and shells) before addition to test
     chambers.

     5.2.5  Sample Processing Method Reference 

     U.S. EPA.  1995.  Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
     Program (EMAP): Laboratory Methods Manual-Estuaries, Volume
     1: Biological and Physical Analyses.  U.S. Environmental
     Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development,
     Narragansett, RI.  EPA/620/R-95/008.  

     5.2.6  Sample Processing Method Deviations 

     None 

6.  DATA MANIPULATIONS

     Measurements on a 'per replicate' basis were received from
     an analytical laboratory.  Mean test and control replicate
     mortality and survival were determined as a basis for
     relevant data manipulations.  

  6.1  Name of New or Modified Values 

     SURVIVAL 
     SIG_CONT 

  6.2  Data Manipulation Description 

     6.2.1  SURVIVAL 

     The values under SURVIVAL represent a comparison of the mean
     test survival to the mean control survival.  

     6.2.2  SIG_CONT 

     A one-tailed t-test (alpha=0.05) was used to determine if
     the mean per cent sample mortality was significantly
     different from the mean per cent control mortality.  

  6.3  Data Manipulation Examples 

     6.3.1  SURVIVAL

     ((Mean % Test Survival / Mean % Control Survival) * 100)


7.   Data Description 

  7.1  Description of Parameters 

   Parameter Data                   Parameter
#  SAS Name  Type  Len  Format      Label
-----------------------------------------------------------------
1  STA_NAME  Char    8    8.        The Station Identifier     
2  VST_DATE  Num     8    YYMMDD6.  The Date the Sample was Collected
3  SPECCODE  Char    8    $8.       EMAP Taxon Code            
4  SURVIVAL  Num     8    5.1       % Survival (Samp Mean as % of Control)  
5  SIG_CONT  Char    8    $3.       Sig Diff from Control(Samp x % Mortality)

     7.1.6  Precision to which values are reported 

     Values are reported to one decimal point.

     7.1.7  Minimum Value in Data Set 

     00.0 %

     7.1.8  Maximum Value in Data Set 

     111.5 %

  7.2  Data Record Example

     7.2.1  Column Names for Example Records

     STA_NAME    VST_DATE    SPECCODE    SURVIVAL    SIG_CONT

     7.2.2  Example Data Records

     VA92-451     920810     AMPEABDI     100.0        N     
     VA92-452     920809     AMPEABDI     103.3        N     

8.  GEOGRAPHIC AND SPATIAL INFORMATION 

     8.1  Minimum Longitude 

     -77 Degrees  19 Minutes  51.00 Decimal Seconds

     8.2  Maximum Longitude 

     -69 Degrees  56 Minutes  27.60 Decimal Seconds

     8.3  Minimum Latitude 

     36 Degrees  51 Minutes  51.00 Decimal Seconds

     8.4  Maximum Latitude 

     42 Degrees  05 Minutes  15.49 Decimal Seconds

     8.5  Name of area or region

     Virginian Province 

     Stations were located in estuaries along the East Coast of
     the United States from Cape Cod, Massachusetts, to Cape
     Henry, Virginia, at the mouth of the Chesapeake Bay.  The
     area includes the District of Columbia, Virginia, Maryland,
     Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut,
     Rhode Island and Massachusetts. 

9.  QUALITY CONTROL/QUALITY ASSURANCE

     9.1  Measurement Quality Objectives 

     The required control chart for toxicity testing using a
     reference toxicant should show that the LC50 values should
     fall within 2 standard deviations of the mean.  

     9.2  Quality Assurance/Control Methods 

     QA/QC procedures for sediment toxicity tests involved sample
     handling and storage, source and condition of test
     organisms, condition of facilities and equipment, test
     conditions, instrument calibration, replication, use of
     reference toxicants, record keeping, and data evaluation. 
     All organisms used in the tests were disease-free and were
     positively identified to species.  Organisms collected from
     the field prior to testing were obtained from an area known
     to be free of toxicants and were held in clean,
     uncontaminated water and facilities.  If greater than five
     percent of the organisms in holding containers were dead or
     appeared unhealthy during the 48 hours preceding a test, the
     entire group was discarded.  

     The sensitivity of A. abdita collected from the field was
     evaluated with a water-only 48-hour reference toxicant test
     (sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)) performed concurrently with
     each sediment toxicity test.  A control chart was prepared
     and successive toxicity values were plotted and examined to
     determine if the results were within prescribed limits.  In
     this technique, a running plot was maintained for the
     toxicity values from successive tests with a given reference
     toxicant.  For regression analysis results (such as LC50s),
     the mean and upper and lower control limits (+2 Standard
     Deviations) were recalculated with each successive point
     until the statistics stabilized.  Values which fell outside
     the upper and lower control limits and trends of increasing
     or decreasing sensitivity could be readily identified.  At
     the P=0.05 probability level, one in twenty tests would be
     expected to fall outside of the control limits by chance
     alone.  If the toxicity value from a given test with the
     reference toxicant did not fall in the expected range for
     the test organisms, the sensitivity of the organisms and the
     overall credibility of the test would be suspect.  In this
     case, the test procedure would have been examined for
     defects and, if possible, the test would have been repeated
     with a different batch of test organisms.

     A 10-day sediment toxicity test was considered unacceptable
     if one or more of the following occurred:

     1.   All test chambers were not identical.
     2.   Treatments were not randomly assigned to test chambers.
     3.   Test organisms were not randomly or impartially
          distributed to test chambers.
     4.   Required control treatments were not included in the
          test.
     5.   All test animals were not from the same population,
          were not all of the same species or were not a
          acceptable quality.
     6.   Amphipods from a wild population were maintained in the
          laboratory for more than two weeks, unless the effects
          of prolonged maintenance in the laboratory has been
          shown to have no significant effect on sensitivity.
     7.   The test organisms were not acclimated at the test
          temperature and salinity at least 48 h before they were
          placed in the test chambers.
     8.   Temperature, dissolved oxygen, and concentration of
          test material were not measured or were not within the
          ranges specified:

          Temperature:  20oC+3oC for individual readings, 20oC+1oC
          time-weighted average temperature at the end of the
          test, no more than 2oC difference among chambers
          measured concurrently.

          Salinity:  30 ppt. 

          Dissolved Oxygen:  DO concentration was maintained at
          >90% saturation, should never have dropped below 60%
          saturation.  

     9.   Aeration to the test chambers was off for an extended
          time such that dissolved oxygen levels dropped to less
          than 60 % of saturation.
     10.  Response criteria were not monitored in a "blind"
          fashion, i.e., observers had knowledge of the treatment
          of sediments in the test chambers.
     11.  Mean percent survival of organisms in control
          treatments was less than 85% or survival in an
          individual control test chamber was less than 80%.

  9.3  Actual Measurement Quality 

     The laboratory's control chart showed that the LC50 for the
     reference toxicant, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) ranged from
     <2.57 to 11.2 mg/l, with all but the lowest value falling
     within two standard deviations of the mean, as required in
     the QA Plan (one in 20 tests would be expected to fall
     outside of two standard deviations). Results of the one
     reference toxicity test falling outside two standard
     deviations of the mean were examined, as were all tests
     performed during the same time period.  No anomalies in the
     tests were apparent and no re-testing was performed.  

     All tests were used in EMAP's assessment of the ecological
     condition of the Province.  

  9.4  Sources of Error

     Factors potentially affecting results from static sediment
     toxicity tests might include:

     -    Alteration of field sediments in preparation for
          laboratory testing.  Maintaining the integrity of the
          sediment environment during its removal, transport, and
          testing in the laboratory is extremely difficult.  The
          sediment environment is composed of a myriad of
          microenvironments, redox gradients, and other
          interacting physicochemical and biological processes. 
          Many of these characteristics influence sediment
          toxicity and bioavailability to benthic and planktonic
          organism, microbial degradation, and chemical sorption. 
          Any disruption of this environment complicates
          interpretations of treatment effect, causative factors,
          and in situ comparisons.  Testing of sediments at
          temperatures or salinities other than those at which
          they were collected might affect contaminant
          solubility, partitioning coefficients, and other
          physical and chemical characteristics.  

     -    Interactions between the sediment particles, overlying
          water, interstitial water, and humic substances, and
          the sediment to overlying water ratio.

     -    Interactions among chemicals which may be present in
          test sediment.

     -    Photolysis and other processes degrading test
          chemicals.

     -    Resuspension of sediment during the toxicity test.

     -    Natural geochemical properties of test sediment
          collected from the field which may not be within the
          tolerance limits of the test organisms.

     -    Recovery of test organisms from the test system.

     -    Endemic organisms which may be present in field
          collected sediments including predators, species which
          may be the same as or closely related to the test
          species, or microorganisms (e.g., bacteria, molds) and
          algae colonizing sediment and test chamber surfaces.

     Static tests might not be applicable to materials that are
     highly volatile or are rapidly biologically or chemically
     transformed.  Furthermore, the overlying water quality may
     change considerably from the initial overlying water. 
     Because the experimental chambers are aerated, the
     procedures can usually be applied to materials that have a
     high oxygen demand.  Materials dissolved in interstitial
     waters might be removed from solution in substantial
     quantities by adsorption to sediment particles and to the
     test chamber during the test.  The dynamics of contaminant
     partitioning between solid and dissolved phases at the
     initiation of the test should therefore be considered,
     especially in relation to assumptions of chemical
     equilibrium.

10. DATA ACCESS

  10.1 Data Access Procedures 

     A Data Request Package can be requested from a contact under
     Section 10.3.  Data can be downloaded from the WWW site. 

  10.2 Data Access Restrictions 

  10.3 Data Access Contact Persons

     John Paul, Ph.D, 
     U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED 
     (401) 782-3037 (Tel.)
     (401) 782-3030 (FAX)
     paul.john@epamail.epa.gov

     Data Librarian, EMAP-Estuaries 
     U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED 
     (401) 782-3184 (Tel.)
     (401) 782-3030 (FAX)
     hughes.melissa@epamail.epa.gov

  10.4 Data Set Format

     Data can be transmitted in a variety of formats derived from
     SAS data sets.

  10.5 Information Concerning Anonymous FTP

     Not accessible

  10.6 Information Concerning Gopher and WWW

     Data can be downloaded from the WWW site 

  10.5 EMAP CD_ROM Containing the Data Set 

     Data not available on CD-ROM


11. REFERENCES

Holland, A.F., ed.  1990.  Near Coastal Program Plan for 1990: 
     Estuaries.  EPA 600/4-90/033.  U.S. EPA, NHEERL-AED, Office
     of Research and Development, Narragansett, RI.  November
     1990.

Schimmel, S. C., 1990.  Implementation Plan for the 
     Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program.  Near
     Coastal Demonstration Project. Narragansett Contribution No. 
     1178.  U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED, Narragansett, RI.  

Reifsteck, D.R., Strobel, C.J. and S.C. Schimmel. 1992. Environmental
     Monitoring and Assessment Program-Estuaries:  1992 Virginian
     Province Effort Field Operations and Safety Manual. U.S. EPA 
     NHEERL-AED, Narragansett, RI.  June 1992. 

U.S. EPA.  1995.  Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program
     (EMAP): Laboratory Methods Manual-Estuaries, Volume 1:
     Biological and Physical Analyses.  U.S. Environmental
     Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development,
     Narragansett, RI.  EPA/620/R-95/008.  

Valente, R., C.J. Strobel and S.C. Schimmel. 1992.  Environmental
     Monitoring and Assessment Program-Estuaries 1992 Virginian
     Province Quality Assurance Project Plan.  U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED, 
     Narragansett, RI.  July 1992.

Weisberg, S.B., J.B. Frithsen, A.F. Holland, J.F. Paul, K.J.
     Scott, J.K. Summers, H.T. Wilson, R. Valente, D.G. Heimbuch,
     J. Gerritsen, S.C. Schimmel and R.W. Latimer, 1993.  EMAP -
     Estuaries Virginian Province 1990 Demonstration Project
     Report.  EPA 620/R-93/006.  U.S. Environmental Protection
     Agency, NHEERL-AED, Narragansett, RI  02882-1197. 

12.  TABLE OF ACRONYMS 

13.  PERSONNEL INFORMATION 

     Virginian Province Manager 
     Darryl Keith 
     U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 
     NHEERL-AED
     27 Tarzwell Drive
     Narragansett, RI  02882-1197
     (401)782-3135 (Tel.)
     (401)782-3030 (FAX)
     keith.darryl@epamail.epa.gov

     Quality Assurance Officer, Virginian Province 
     Charles J. Strobel
     U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 
     NHEERL-AED
     27 Tarzwell Drive
     Narragansett, RI  02882-1197
     (401)782-3180 (Tel.)
     (401)782-3030 (FAX)
     strobel.charles@epamail.epa.gov

     Sample Processing-Principal Investigator
     Dr. K. John Scott
     Science Applications International Corporation, Inc. 
     Environmental Testing Center
     165 Dean Knauss Drive
     Narragansett, RI  02882
     (401)782-1900 (Tel.) 

     John Paul, Ph.D. 
     U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
     NHEERL-AED 
     Narragansett, RI  02882-1197
     (401) 782-3037 (Tel.)
     (401) 782-3030 (FAX)
     paul.john@epamail.epa.gov

     Data Librarian, EMAP-Estuaries 
     Melissa M. Hughes
     OAO Corporation  
     U.S. EPA NHEERL-AED 
     Narragansett, RI  02882-1197
     (401) 782-3184 (Tel.)
     (401) 782-3030 (FAX)
     hughes.melissa@epamail.epa.gov               

